2003 Volkswagen Golf TDI diesel

Opinion: push EVs with scrappage – but don’t forget the dirty diesels

Renault Zoe plug-in electric car

The German government has introduced a sales incentive for new electric cars – and the German car industry is incensed.

Up to €9,000 is on offer to electric car buyers, which finally gives EVs price parity with conventional cars. However, there are no incentives for regular cars – and estimates suggest there is €15bn’s worth of them unsold in the German dealer network.

It’s these cars that German car firms want help with shifting.

The intentions of the EV-only incentives are noble. Of course we should help drive people into electric cars. Zero-emissions vehicles are the future.

But not everyone is ready for them or, crucially, can afford them. So how can we help such people do their bit to making the air cleaner?

By not just focusing on getting pure electric onto the road, but also getting dirty old ones off it.

Scrappage: the hybrid route

2003 Volkswagen Golf TDI diesel

There’s growing talk in the UK of a scrappage-style incentive. Given the success of the last scheme, which helped sell 400,000 cars, this should be welcomed. But, unlike Germany, it should not just be focused on EVs.

For starters, there won’t be enough of them to go around. Also, because ordinary motorists might not be able to afford them. It risks giving a saving to those rich enough to buy them, which is hardly egalitarian.

My suggestion is this: incentivise sales of all electrified cars (that’s EV, plug-in hybrid, pure hybrid and mild hybrid), provided they chop in a dirty diesel (or older petrol) for scrappage.

Everything would be included, from the latest mild hybrid Ford Fiestas, to the new Honda Jazz Hybrid, to the plug-in Skoda Superb iV and even the new all-electric Renault Zoe.

All, to a greater or lesser extent, can operate at least some of the time in zero-emissions engine-off mode, so will immediately have an extremely positive effect on emissions and air quality (particularly compared to the car they’d be taking off the road).

Learn from ULEZ

London Ultra Low Emission Zone roadsign

The template is already there. Look at the London Ultra Low Emissions Zone (ULEZ). Who has to pay? Petrol cars that don’t meet Euro 4 emissions (2005 and older)… and diesels that don’t meet Euro 6 (2016 and older).

Even without dieselgate, many of us will be aware that as older diesels get older still, their turbocharged motors emit more and more noxiousness – both visible black smoke, and the more dangerous stuff you can’t see.

In an ideal world, owners would service their cars and keep them in tip-top condition, so this wouldn’t happen. But we’re human, and are you really going to put in your £1,000 Volkswagen Golf TDI for a gold-standard service just to keep the emissions down? For a third of the price of the car itself? Of course not.

Let’s get people out of them. Let’s get them off the road. Let’s clean up local air by incentivising someone out of a grubby diesel and into a modern hybrid.

Electrified cars are the stepping stone into pure, 100% zero emissions electric vehicles. Let’s use a 2020 scrappage scheme to start that journey.


London ULEZ scrappage schemes: how to save money on a new car

Scrappage for season tickets could be on the way

Is petrolgate the new dieselgate scandal?

1 reply
  1. iain Reid
    iain Reid says:

    Electric vehicles are not zero per cent CO2 emission vehicles.
    The electricity to power them comes for fossil fuelled power stations. Despite that we have a mix of generation sources, renewable and nuclear with nil CO2 emissions they don’t supply the power for electric vehicles. Nuclear and renewable give maximum available power at all times, so called non dispatchable power. As these plug in cars are an extra grid load and the largest type of genertor by far that reacts to this load is gas powered, essentially electric vehicles are powered by gas..
    I’ve read university studies on the amount of CO2 emissions due to generation that supply electric vehicles and they make the same mistake of taking an average of all inputs, they don’t understand how the grid works. Even then they all give a CO2 figure directly attributeable to electric vehicles (Never zero though) but all far too low a figure.


Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *