More motorists risk car insurance ‘loyalty tax’

There has been a 40 percent rise in motorists letting their car insurance auto-renew without checking prices – who could be out of pocket by up to £289

September is a peak month for car insurance renewals

This September’s peak car insurance renewal season could be busier than ever – and motorists who let their policy auto-renew rather than checking prices could be out of pocket by up to £289.

Called the auto-renewal ‘loyalty tax’, the number of motorists allowing auto-renewal is actually on the increase.

Research shows the number of auto-renewals has risen 40 percent over the past six months alone, to the highest level since early 2017.

GoCompare is now urging the 6.7 million motorists at risk of paying the car insurance loyalty tax to shop around and check if they could get identical cover for less money.

Lee Griffin, CEO and founder of GoCompare, said: “Our research shows that millions of drivers are not actively engaging with the renewal process this year, potentially leaving themselves hundreds of pounds out of pocket by effectively paying a ‘loyalty tax’.   

“We know insurers are helping those in extreme financial difficulty and, in these circumstances, it could be in the insured’s interest to remain with their current provider. 

“But drivers who are still paying their premiums really need to shop around this year to see what other insurers are willing to offer them.”

Lockdown saw fewer cars on the road, resulting in fewer accidents and claims which led one car insurer to issue automatic refunds.

This trend has continued since lockdown restrictions eased.

However, warned Mr Griffin, while this may mean some motorists are pleasantly surprised to find their auto-renewal quote coming in cheaper than last year, he still urged motorists to shop around.

“That is the signal that they could probably get an even better deal elsewhere.”

Top tips to get a better car insurance deal

  • Never accept your auto-renewal quote, even if it is cheaper than last year, without first checking prices
  • Give yourself at least a week ahead of your renewal date to shop around
  • Make sure you read the small print of new policies, so it is a like-for-like policy with no excess charges, penalties, exclusions or terms and conditions

For those who are facing financial difficulties and whose car insurance is coming up for renewal, GoCompare has also published some specific advice to help, including guidance from regulator the FCA.


How to save money on car insurance

Popular car insurance myths: busted

What do the car insurance write-off categories mean?

Related Articles

Richard Aucock
Richard is director at Motoring Research. He has been with us since 2001, and has been a motoring journalist even longer. He won the IMCO Motoring Writer of the Future Award in 1996 and the acclaimed Sir William Lyons Award in 1998. Both awards are run by the Guild of Motoring Writers and Richard is currently chairman of the world's largest organisation for automotive media professionals. Richard is also a juror for World Car Awards and the UK juror for the AUTOBEST awards.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


We drive a Volvo police car – on a frozen lake

We go sideways in Volvo's police-spec V90 on a frozen lake in Sweden. And we discover what makes it different to a normal car.

Frank Stephenson on the rights and wrongs of car design

Frank Stephenson’s car design CV stretches from the modern Mini to the McLaren P1. We ask about his career and what BMW has been drinking.

Hybrid car sales to continue until 2035

The government confirms that sales of full hybrid vehicles will continue until 2035, five years after the ban on new petrol and diesel cars.

How to secure your car with an OBD port locking device

Criminals are consistently using high-tech equipment to steal cars. This is how to stop your On-Board Diagnostics port being exploited.

Find a Car Review