New tool reveals if you are paying too much for car insurance

A new online tool will tell you if you're paying too much for your car insurance. Drivers in London might want to look away now...

car insurance quote

Nobody likes paying more than they have to for something, especially if it’s car insurance. It’s one of the most expensive and unavoidable costs of motoring.

According to recent figures from MoneySuperMarket, the average cost of a comprehensive car insurance policy is £475. This is a six percent fall compared to six months ago, and two percent lower than 12 months ago.

The average price is just that: an average. Higher risk groups, such as young drivers will pay more, as will consumers in high-risk postcodes. Which is where the new CompareTheMarket insurance tool comes in.

Simply input your area, age, value of your car and current car insurance premium to find if you’re getting a good deal. Unsurprisingly, the most expensive premiums are found in London, but you might be surprised by the difference between the highest and lowest prices.

London calling

Do I need to declare an accident

Newham is the most expensive area, with drivers paying an average of £1,521.66 in the London borough. This is followed by Tower Hamlets (£1,366.69), Brent (£1,324.92) and Hackney (£1,301.23).

Island living is recommended if you want to pay the least for car insurance. Three out of the four cheapest regions are islands, with residents of the Isles of Scilly paying just £329.45 a year. Only West Devon prevents the Orkney Islands and Isle of Wight from completing an island one-two-three.

There are 408 regions in the CompareTheMarket tool, with all but 13 showing a more expensive price than the MoneySuperMarket average. One thing’s clear: where you live plays a massive role in how much you pay for cover.

Six out of the 15 cheapest regions are in Devon. Meanwhile, 14 out of the 15 most expensive locations are in the Greater London area. Manchester is the 11th most expensive area in the UK.

The most costly areas for car insurance

  1. Newham: £1,521.66
  2. Tower Hamlets: £1,366.69
  3. Brent: £1,324.92
  4. Hackney: £1,301.23
  5. Barking and Dagenham: £1,295.74
  6. Westminster: £1,279.36
  7. Redbridge: £1,267.36
  8. Haringey: £1,262.19
  9. Kensington and Chelsea: £1,231.70
  10. Enfield: £1,220.51

The cheapest areas for car insurance

  1. Isles of Scilly: £329.45
  2. Orkney Islands: £442.05
  3. West Devon: £445.65
  4. Isle of Wight: £447.04
  5. Torridge: £449.72
  6. East Devon: £456.40
  7. Kerrier: £463.92
  8. North Norfolk: £465.19
  9. Fareham: £466.01
  10. East Lothian: £467.98

Click here for the full data and the research methodology.

Related Articles

Gavin Braithwaite-Smith
Writer with a penchant for #FrenchTat. Also doing a passable impression of Cousin Eddie in an Italian-German beige motorhome.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Fiat Tipo Cross leads facelifted family hatch range

The Fiat Tipo Cross is an SUV-style crossover range-topper for the facelifted Tipo range – and all models get a distinctive new front end

Citroen cuts prices with new ‘Fair Pricing’ strategy

The Citroen Advance UK strategy aims to turn around the brand in the UK, with better value, new cars and a focus on customer satisfaction.

Mini John Cooper Works GP (2020) review

With a top speed of 164mph, the two-seat John Cooper Works GP is the fastest Mini ever. We go for a wild ride

Rolls-Royce Ghost (2010) review

Short of things to do, we go in search of the nation’s best fish and chips in a Rolls-Royce Ghost. It's how the other half live...