Rising car insurance excess warning to motorists

Excesses of £3,000 and beyond are becoming more common, reveals new research. Drivers could be left without a payout in the event of a write-off

car insurance excesses rising

New research into what drivers are paying for their car insurance has revealed high excess figures are becoming increasingly commonplace. 

Excesses that exceed £3,000 are being quoted on older cars, despite the fact the write-off value would be significantly lower.

That means, in the event of the car being a total loss, the driver would receive nothing.

Researchers at the Mail on Sunday searched for car insurance on moneysupermarket.com. The average car on UK roads is eight years old, so the search used one of the most popular used cars, a Ford Fiesta, registered in 2012, for a 40-year-old driver in South London.

The value of such a vehicle should be between £3,440, and £3,775. The write-off figure would be around 50 percent of this. 

Car insurance auto renewal costs

Six insurers came back with staggering £3,000 compulsory excess figures. These insurers were not even the cheapest, either.

The same surprise might be in store for owners of more expensive cars. An eight-year-old BMW 3 Series with a value of £7,000 to £7,500, generated five quotes with a £3,000 excess for a 40-year-old in Stevenage.

With the average car insurance claim costing £2,600, it pays to keep a close eye on what excesses are on your policy.

The British Insurance Brokers’ Association (BIBA) claims one of the reasons insurers offer high excesses is that they’d rather do so than decline insurance altogether. In short, such excesses are a get-around for ‘no-quotes’.

When is cheapest to buy car insurance

“Policy excesses are often misunderstood and can provide a nasty shock during a claim – a time when there is already enough stress to deal with,” said Anders Nilsson, from gocompare.com.

“Our research shows excesses could contribute to genuine financial hardship with 37 per cent of drivers admitting they don’t have the means to pay their excess or would have to turn to credit cards or loans.”

What is car insurance excess?

Car insurance October 2019

The excess on car insurance is what the driver pays before the insurer begins to contribute, in the case of repairing their own vehicle.

For example, consider a single-car incident and all that’s damaged is the front bumper and the driver’s sidelight. If the excess on their policy is £500, and the total cost of the damage is £800, to get the car back on the road, the insurer will contribute £300 to that. 

If the damage is below £500, the insurer won’t contribute anything. The excess is only payable on damage to your own vehicle. Damage to other’s vehicles, and the associated costs, if you are at fault, is on your insurer.

Related Articles

Ethan Jupp
I'm Content Editor at MR. Road trips music and movies are my vices. Perennially stuck between French hot hatches and Australian muscle cars.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


How to assign a private number plate online

Adding a private number plate to your car is a simple process using the DVLA’s online form. Here's what you need to know.

Mini John Cooper Works GP (2020) review

With a top speed of 164mph, the two-seat John Cooper Works GP is the fastest Mini ever. We go for a wild ride

Tiff Needell returns to TV in new ITV4 motoring show

Lovecars: On the Road sees former Top Gear and Fifth Gear presenter Tiff Needell back on television, driving an array of new cars.

Citroen cuts prices with new ‘Fair Pricing’ strategy

The Citroen Advance UK strategy aims to turn around the brand in the UK, with better value, new cars and a focus on customer satisfaction.