Luxury cars are the most likely to break down

While city cars are the most reliable, says Which?

Modern luxury cars are the most likely to breakdown

The most expensive new cars on the market are the most likely to go wrong within three years, a survey by consumer group Which? has found.

As part of its annual Which? car survey, drivers revealed that more than a third (36%) of luxury cars require a trip to the garage within the first three years. That’s despite the average luxury car buyer spending more than £49,000 on their new motor.

The faults are likely to be caused by the complicated technology used in luxury cars – with complex infotainment and sophisticated safety systems likely to cause big bills when out of warranty.

City car drivers, meanwhile, spend the least on their car (£10,108 on average) – but only a quarter go wrong within three years, making them the most reliable cars available.

The survey revealed the most reliable luxury car you can buy is a Tesla Model S, although even this is plagued with faults, scoring only three stars out of five for reliability.

Nearly a third of Model S owners reported issues, most commonly to do with handles or locks for the boot or door. Which? also says it’s heard of issues with seat belts and rainwater seals on the Tesla.

Not that this seems to deter the cars’ owners. “It is quite simply the best car I have ever driven. It is economical, efficient, smooth and effortless to drive,” said one Tesla owner.


Related news on Motoring Research:


Although the latest Jaguar XF has only been out two years, Which? says 42% of owners that took part in its survey have had issues with their car, making it the least reliable luxury car available. One owner said: “A car of its price that leaks water into the door and one of the exterior door seals peels off. [It indicates a] poor quality build.”

As part of the survey, the organisation questioned 44,794 owners about 50,742 cars.

Related Articles

Andrew Brady
Andrew Brady
Web editor at MR. Drives a 2005 Toyota MR2. Has a penchant for the peculiar.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Skoda confirms UK prices for new electric Elroq vRS

The electric Elroq vRS is Skoda's fastest-accelerating production car to date, hitting 62mph in just 5.4 seconds.

Evidence shows EV batteries are lasting longer than expected

A leasing company has tested more than 8,000 electric cars after long-term use and discovered that EV batteries are proving very robust.

New Range Rover Electric seen undisguised in cold weather tests

Accumulating up to 45,000 miles of cold weather testing, the Range Rover Electric has been pushed to the limit in Sweden

Genesis heads to Le Mans with GMR-001 Hypercar

Genesis used the New York Auto Show to announce its plans for endurance racing from 2026, with the GMR-001 competing in the LMDh class.